The Luminaries by Eleanor Catton: A Review

the_luminaries_a_pThe Luminaries

Eleanor Catton

I rate it: 8/10

Six word summary: murky conundrum in NZ gold mines

 Any reader who takes a book of more than 800 pages in hand knows that there is a 70% chance that she will lose interest midway. This says nothing about attention deficiency in the reader, or lack of skill in the writing, it is merely the nature of the beast. A really long book, whether it is a saga or a murder mystery, will sag at points, will over-elaborate, and will generally not know where to sensibly stop. We know these things through many years of reading experience.

 Eleanor Catton’s Booker winning marble slab of a book defies most of these things we know. It weaves a complex storyline, occasionally baffling even the most perceptive readers, but not once in its 832 pages does it lose pace or become boring.

 Twelve men meet at the Crown Hotel in Hokitika, New Zealand, in January, 1866, to discuss and get to the bottom of some extremely peculiar incidents that have been taking place in the mining town in the past fortnight. A penniless recluse has been found dead with an enormous amount of pure gold in his keeping. A prostitute has attempted suicide or been poisoned. A very wealthy young man has gone missing. And each of the twelve men in the gathering have been implicated in some way or the other. Each has something to share and something to hide, something to explain and something to understand, some prejudices and some bafflement. Walter Moody, fresh off the boat and grappling with recent horrors, stumbles upon this assembly quite by accident, and becomes entangled in the events that are causing such turmoil in the tiny township. Gleaming in the background are trails of blackmail, betrayal, lust, villainy, black magic, and murder most foul.

Luminaries 2

 I liked several things about The Luminaries, but what I liked the most, I think, is the depth of back-story and human logic the writer builds behind almost all of the characters. With a light touch, she gives these people driving forces of not merely thick-brushed sentiments like love, hate, wrath, or envy, but also fine-stroked ones like loneliness, bewilderment, nostalgia, longing, alienation, annoyance, hubris, and desire to please, that an ordinary reader like me could identify with. I think it was Death of the Endless that said something like it is impossible to not love somebody if you know them like they know themselves, and through the course of this book, we learn so much about these men (and woman) that they tug at our heartstrings. My only gripe is that the two villains are not really given this treatment, leaving them as two-dimensional cartoon villains that are driven by greed, lust, and hate. I think it would have been a tremendous achievement for Ms. Catton if she could have made me empathize with Francis Carver and Lydia Wells.


 The other thing I enjoyed was the fact that, having created a deeply convoluted plot, Eleanor Catton doesn’t spoil it by over-explaining. She lets readers put two and two together, giving us plenty of “Oh!’ and “Aha! So that’s how..” moments. I’ve said it before in my review of Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall– an author who respects the intelligence of her readers is a rare delight.

 A lot has been written about the daring structure of this novel. Apparently, each chapter is progressively exactly half the size of its preceding chapter, such that in the last few pieces, the summary introduction is actually longer than the chapter itself. Also the chapters reflect the various phases of the moon or astro-charts or something. Frankly, I could take that or leave it. I hadn’t even noticed it while reading. I’ve said it before, I’m sold on the story and the telling every time. The structure can go pleasure itself.


 Even as I lavish so much praise on The Luminaries, I know pretty certainly that it is not a book for everybody. It’s really long, needs a lot of patience and careful reading, and there is far too much dialogue and very little action. All the same, I’m with the Man Booker jury on this one, The luminaries is a stunning piece of fiction, and you should at least try it before you meh it.

 gold rushIt took me seven and a half hours to read The Luminaries from cover to cover, but I should not leave off mentioning that it took me three weekends to actually get around to reading it in one sitting (or bed-lounging, whatever). It was too heavy for me to carry on my commute, and I could only read it on weekends. Every time I tried to pick up where I left off, I found I had forgotten who was who and who did what, so I had to start over again. This happened trice before I stayed up all night one Friday to slay the beast once and for all.

 Took a very long break from reviewing. Great to be back, y’all!

 -Amritorupa “what is mine is mine” Kanjilal 

While you are here, have a look at:

7 Responses to The Luminaries by Eleanor Catton: A Review

  1. Great review. Good to have you back. I feel a bit daunted by the idea of this book, but it’s intriguing at the same time. I think I probably would keep notes on who is who. I sometimes do that when and book has many characters. Thanks for the great review!

    • Thank you Judith. actually, the book begins with a list of the characters and who they are, but the problem is, emotional connect is important in this book, and that sort of wore away when i stayed away from the book for too long.

  2. Lovely review. I would dearly love to sink my teeth into this one. I see it does need a lot of concentration and close reading, so I need to get into the right mind space for this one.

  3. What a great review. Thank you so much. I spent quite a while thumbing through the book just tonight, wondering if it would be a good next read for my reading partner and I. The size of the book is daunting and I only want to start it when I know I have some really good uninterrupted schedule to read through it without too much stopping along the way.
    You answered some important questions for me, one being the significance of all the astrological rigarmarole I see in the structure of the book. According to to you, it does not matter all that much — and this is encouraging because a) I think astrology is silly, and b) I don’t want to be reading a book that is like…. Umberto Eco-ish deep right now.

    • Thank you Cipriano. the ‘moon in taurus’ and ‘sun in pisces’ sounded all grand and enigmatic, but thankfully had no bearing on the story or i would not have been able to make any sense of it at all. Maybe somebody who actually understands these things will be able to interpret this aspect better.
      BTW, this was more old-timey astronomy rather than astrology.

  4. The Great India Righter

    Dear Sir/Madam,

    I am the great Indian righter and am pleased to inform you that I am another entrant contributing to the plethora of useful and profound fiction that is being churned by so many talented Indian writers who have taken the bowels out of the vowels and are interested in expressing themselves by any means possible.

    Now that the big publishers have also pandered to this molestation of the language, I take delight in telling you that my book based on my true life incident titled, “I HAD TOO MANY LOVE STORIES. NOW I AM DECLARED MENTAL IN 2 STATES” is already a self-proclaimed internationally national best seller.

    Please be kind as to review the same.



    I am in anticipation, for ever and ever,


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>